Businesses have history.
People join early, take on whatever needs doing & gradually collect responsibilities. Someone starts in Sales, picks up Marketing, ends up overseeing Customer Service because nobody else owns it & somehow becomes responsible for IT because they once knew how to restart the router.
Ten years later, the structure still reflects all those old decisions.
“This reports to Sarah because it always has.”
“John has always looked after that.”
“We can’t move this function because David built it.”
“She needs to stay there because she’s been with us from the beginning.”
None of those statements tells me what the business actually needs now.
That is when your Accountability Chart® starts looking less like a deliberate business structure & more like a family tree.
Structure Should Follow the Business, Not the History
One of the biggest mistakes leadership teams make is designing structure around the people they already have.
They start with names.
- Who is here now?
- What do they currently do?
- Who reports to whom?
- How can we arrange all of that into something that looks sensible?
That is understandable, but it is backwards.
The better question is:
What structure does this business need over the next six to 12 months?
Only once you are clear on that should you decide which people belong in which seats.
The Accountability Chart is not supposed to preserve history. It is supposed to clarify the major functions of the business, define who owns what & show where accountability sits.
That means you sometimes need to forget the people temporarily & design the structure first.
Then you add the people back in.
That can be uncomfortable, because it may reveal that someone’s current role exists largely because it evolved that way rather than because the business genuinely needs it.
But that is useful information.
Stop Building Seats Around People
Another common problem is creating roles around an individual rather than around the work the business needs done.
You have someone who is brilliant with customers, good with numbers & reasonably strong operationally, so you create a hybrid role around everything they happen to be capable of doing.
It works for a while.
Then the business grows.
Now nobody quite knows whether Customer Service belongs with Sales or Operations. Finance has responsibilities sitting in three different places. A new leader is hired, but half their role is already owned informally by someone else.
The structure becomes dependent on personalities rather than clarity.
This is particularly dangerous when long-serving employees have accumulated responsibilities over time.
Their role may make perfect sense when you look at the person.
It makes very little sense when you look at the business.
The Accountability Chart should describe the seats the organisation needs, not document all the jobs people have slowly collected.
Titles Can Hide a Lot of Confusion
Traditional organisational charts often focus heavily on titles.
- Chief Operating Officer.
- Head of Sales.
- Marketing Manager.
- General Manager.
Those titles can sound clear while hiding enormous ambiguity underneath.
- What does the person actually own?
- What are they accountable for?
- Where does their responsibility end?
- What decisions can they make?
- What belongs to somebody else?
Two people can have completely different interpretations of the same title.
That is why the conversation needs to go deeper than hierarchy.
If someone sits in the Sales seat, what are the key accountabilities of that seat?
If someone owns Operations, what genuinely belongs there?
If the Integrator owns the day-to-day execution of the business, what decisions should they be able to make without the founder stepping back in?
Clarity comes from defining the seat properly, not giving it an impressive title.
One Person Can Sit in More Than One Seat
There is nothing inherently wrong with one person occupying several seats, particularly in a smaller business.
The founder may own Sales as well as another leadership function.
A Finance leader may temporarily own HR.
Someone may be holding a seat until the business is large enough to justify another hire.
That is fine.
The important thing is that the seats remain distinct.
Why?
Because eventually the business may need to separate them.
If Sales & Marketing are genuinely two different functions but one person currently owns both, show that clearly.
Do not merge them into one vague seat simply because one person happens to do both today.
The structure should show what the business needs, not just what the current payroll can support.
That makes future growth much easier.
Two People Cannot Really Own the Same Thing
The opposite problem is shared ownership.
This is where businesses get into real trouble.
Two people both think they own Customer Experience.
Three leaders are jointly responsible for recruitment.
The founder & Operations leader both believe they have final authority on delivery.
Everyone is “involved”, but nobody is quite sure who is truly accountable.
Shared input is fine.
Shared accountability is usually not.
Several people can contribute to a result, but there still needs to be one person who owns the outcome.
Without that, decisions slow down, Issues bounce between departments & the founder often becomes the default tie-breaker.
Eventually the organisation learns that nobody really owns anything until the most senior person steps in.
That is not a structure.
That is escalation disguised as collaboration.
Founders Often Stay in Seats Too Long
This is another pattern I see regularly.
The business grows, leaders are hired, responsibilities are supposedly handed over, but the founder remains mentally attached to the seat.
They still approve the decisions.
They still speak directly to the team.
They still jump in when something goes wrong.
They still make the final call because “it’s quicker”.
On the Accountability Chart®, someone else owns the function.
In reality, the founder still does.
That creates a horrible situation for the person supposedly sitting in the seat.
They are accountable for the result without genuinely having the authority to create it.
Then the founder becomes frustrated because the leader is not taking enough ownership.
The leader becomes frustrated because the founder will not let them.
And everyone else learns to wait for the founder.
If you have genuinely handed over a seat, you need to let the person own it.
That does not mean disappearing.
It means being clear about where their authority begins & where yours ends.
Growth Changes the Seats
The structure that worked brilliantly when you had 15 people may be completely wrong at 50.
The structure that worked at $3 million in revenue may not support the business at $10 million.
That does not mean the original structure was bad.
It means the business has changed.
Roles become larger.
Functions separate.
New leadership capability is required.
Decision-making becomes more complex.
Sometimes a person who was perfect for a seat three years ago is no longer the right fit because the seat itself has changed significantly.
That can be a difficult conversation, particularly when the person has been loyal, capable & instrumental in getting the business to where it is today.
But changing the structure is not automatically a judgement on the person.
The question is not:
“Has this person been valuable?”
The question is:
“What does the business need from this seat now?”
Those are very different questions.
Long Service Does Not Equal Permanent Ownership
History matters.
Loyalty matters.
Contribution matters.
But none of those things create permanent ownership of a function.
This is where leadership teams can get stuck emotionally.
Someone has been managing an area for eight years, so nobody wants to suggest it should now sit somewhere else.
The person who built a department feels naturally attached to it.
A founder feels they owe someone because of everything that person did in the early years.
That history deserves respect.
But respect does not mean freezing the structure forever.
In fact, keeping someone in an outdated role can eventually become unfair to them too.
They may be trying to succeed in a seat that no longer matches their strengths, capacity or experience.
Sometimes redesigning the structure gives a good person a much better opportunity to succeed.
Your Accountability Chart Should Create Better Decisions
A strong Accountability Chart should help people understand who owns what without needing another meeting to work it out.
When an Issue appears, people should know where it belongs.
When a decision needs to be made, the person with authority should be clear.
When a measurable is off track, there should be no confusion about who owns the outcome.
When somebody says, “I thought they were doing that”, the structure should help expose why the confusion existed.
That is the practical value.
It reduces friction.
It helps Issues get solved closer to where the work happens.
It prevents everything from flowing upwards.
And it gives leaders the clarity they need to take genuine accountability.
Review the Structure Before You Review the People
If your Accountability Chart has not changed in a long time, it is worth looking at it again with fresh eyes.
But start with the business, not the individuals.
Ask:
- What are the major functions the business needs today?
- What will it need over the next six to 12 months?
- Is each function clearly owned?
- Are any seats overloaded?
- Are responsibilities duplicated?
- Are there functions that effectively have no owner?
- Are there people sitting in roles because of history rather than fit?
- And if you removed every name from the chart, would you design the structure the same way?
That last question can be particularly revealing.
If the answer is no, you have some work to do.
Design for Where You Are Going
Your Accountability Chart should not be a historical record.
It should help the leadership team build the organisation the business needs next.
That means being willing to challenge old reporting lines, separate functions that have become too large, clarify authority & occasionally move people into different seats.
Some of those conversations will be uncomfortable.
That is fine.
Clarity is more useful than preserving a structure simply because everyone is accustomed to it.
So, the next time somebody says:
“But that’s how we’ve always done it.”
Ask a better question:
“If we were designing this business today, would we still do it this way?”
Because your Accountability Chart is not a family tree.
It does not exist to preserve where everyone came from.
It exists to show clearly what the business needs, who owns it & how the organisation is going to move forward.